Who This Article Is For
- Owners seeing weaker results from existing initiatives
- Managers whose teams work hard without growing
- Business operators looking for ways beyond a growth plateau
Recognize Diminishing Returns and Redirect Resources Toward New Growth
Spot diminishing returns in marketing, working hours, and existing businesses, then assess additional results and redirect resources before growth stalls.
Published
Review Resource Allocation When Additional Investment Produces Less
Repeating the same effort does not keep increasing results at the same rate. Beyond a certain point, the gain from additional effort becomes smaller. This is the idea of diminishing returns.
A once-effective initiative slows down. Sales fail to keep pace with increased advertising spending. Additional overtime produces little extra output. These patterns can reflect the limits of the current approach.
Review where effort is directed, alongside how much effort is being made.
What Are Diminishing Returns?
Diminishing returns describe a situation in which adding more of an input produces progressively smaller additional gains.
The idea originated in agriculture. Adding labor or fertilizer to a limited area of land initially raises output. Beyond a certain point, the gains slow and efficiency declines.
The same perspective is useful in business.
Examples include:
- Increasing advertising spending
- Adding salespeople
- Extending working hours
- Continuing investment in an existing product
Results may rise strongly at first, then the additional gain shrinks as the same approach continues. Companies often interpret this slowdown as insufficient effort, even when too many resources are concentrated in the same place.
What Companies With Slowing Results Have in Common
Diminishing returns can affect many companies. Previously successful companies can be particularly vulnerable because they have a proven approach they are reluctant to change.
Dependence on a Successful Initiative
Once an initiative succeeds, it becomes the accepted answer. Budget and people keep flowing toward it.
Examples include:
- Continually increasing search-ad spending after it produced growth
- Repeating the same trade-show exhibit after an early success
- Promoting only the product that previously sold well
This is initially reasonable. Eventually, however, the approach can saturate. After reaching the most responsive customers, efficiency falls. A strong memory of success can make changing course difficult.
Trying to Solve the Problem With More Volume
When results slow, many organizations increase activity.
- Run more advertising
- Make more calls
- Hold more meetings
- Work more overtime
If additional inputs are producing smaller gains, increasing volume worsens efficiency.
Profit margins can fall and employees become exhausted. This structure helps explain why people may feel unrewarded despite working hard.
Three Areas Where Returns Diminish
Diminishing returns can appear throughout a company, especially in marketing, labor, and business investment.
Marketing Investment
Advertising and promotion initially reach responsive audiences. Larger budgets can then extend the message to people less likely to respond.
Changes include:
| Input | Early stage | Later stage |
|---|---|---|
| Advertising spending | A small budget produces results | Additional spending produces weaker gains |
| Social media activity | Novelty generates response | Repeating the same message reduces response |
| Sales promotions | Short-term sales rise | More customers wait for discounts |
Look at growth relative to additional investment, alongside the totals.
Working Hours
Longer hours increase output only up to a point. Beyond that, concentration declines, decision errors increase, and more work must be redone.
Consequences include:
- Lower output per hour
- Extra time spent correcting mistakes
- Greater organizational losses through exhaustion and turnover
Additional working hours can eventually add more cost than profit.
Investment in an Existing Business
Successful businesses also mature. Investment may translate readily into growth while a market is expanding, but conditions change as it matures.
- The market becomes saturated
- Competitors increase
- Differentiation becomes harder
- Pressure to reduce prices intensifies
Continuing the same investment in the same product may then produce little growth. Yet a former core business can keep attracting budget, slowing the company overall.
To reconsider allocations among businesses, see using PPM analysis to clarify the role of each business. It provides a framework for considering each unit from the perspective of the company as a whole.
Change Strategy to Move Beyond a Plateau
You cannot eliminate diminishing returns, but recognizing them early leaves options. Reallocate resources instead of simply adding more to the same destination.
Judge the Additional Result
Consider how much a result increases relative to the additional resources invested, alongside total sales.
For example:
- How much extra revenue followed an additional JPY 100,000 in advertising?
- How much extra gross profit followed hiring one more person?
- How much extra output followed additional overtime?
Totals can still look healthy even after incremental results have begun to weaken.
Diversify Investment
Depending entirely on one initiative exposes the company to its diminishing returns. Spread investment across different opportunities.
Examples include:
- Building referrals alongside advertising
- Testing new products alongside existing ones
- Separating existing-customer initiatives from new-customer acquisition
The purpose is finding the next area of growth, while also providing resilience against risk.
Develop the Next Pillar Early
Waiting until the current business slows is dangerous because fewer resources remain available.
While the core business is still working:
- Test small new initiatives
- Validate new products
- Develop new channels
Build the next pillar while there is capacity to do so. Waiting for difficulty limits the resources available to begin.
SpreadSite is a no-code website builder that lets you create, publish, and update a website from Google Sheets using ready-made templates.
To test a new website presence without taking on a large development project, give SpreadSite a try!
Build a website with SpreadSite →
About the Author
Thank you for reading!
I develop and operate SpreadSite, a service for creating websites from spreadsheets.
It helps people with limited time and money communicate what makes their work appealing. Consider it if you need a website! SpreadSite
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: How can I tell when diminishing returns have begun?
A: Examine gains relative to additional investment. If extra advertising, personnel spending, or working hours produce progressively smaller increases, returns are diminishing.
Q: Doesn’t slowing performance mean insufficient effort?
A: Not necessarily. Continuing to concentrate resources in one place can reduce additional gains. At that stage, review allocation alongside activity volume.
Q: Is this important for smaller companies?
A: Yes. Limited resources make it especially important. Continuing to fund an inefficient initiative reduces the options available elsewhere.
Q: Should we try new things while the existing business is profitable?
A: Yes. Profit provides resources to develop the next pillar. Waiting until performance has weakened makes that harder.
Q: Can diminishing returns be prevented completely?
A: No. Early recognition, attention to incremental results, and diversified investment can reduce the effect on growth.
