Who This Article Is For
- Owners reconsidering slow employee development
- Managers whose on-the-job training is not working well
- Professionals identifying their next development step
Use the Dreyfus Model to Match Guidance With Skill Development
Recognize five skill-development stages by how people make judgments, then adjust procedures, examples, autonomy, and reflection to fit their current needs.
Published
Identify How Someone Judges and Adjust Procedures and Autonomy
A mismatch between instruction and the person’s current stage can slow growth. Too much discretion for a beginner and excessive detail for an experienced person can both interfere.
The Dreyfus model considers five stages of skill acquisition. Identifying the stage helps clarify what to teach and what to entrust.
What the Model Describes
Assess what someone relies on to make a judgment, beyond years of experience.
A beginner needs rules, while someone experienced sees a broader situation. Ignoring that difference creates mismatched coaching.
Examples include:
- Abstract instructions for a beginner
- Excessive detail for a developing practitioner
- No room to make mistakes at a more capable stage
- Leaving expert judgment unarticulated
The model offers a map for reducing those gaps.
Why Development Can Stall
An experienced person may struggle to explain an almost automatic judgment. “Read the situation” gives a new employee little to use.
Conversely, fixed detailed instructions can remove thinking opportunities for someone already capable. Review the developmental match rather than assuming an ability problem.
Five Stages
The basis for judgment and required support change over time.
Novice and Advanced Beginner
A novice needs concrete steps because priorities and relevant cues are unfamiliar.
Typical characteristics include:
- Following a manual
- Stalling on exceptions
- Difficulty prioritizing
- Focusing on steps before background
An advanced beginner recognizes some similar situations. Judgment can still be fragmented and influenced by particular successes or failures rather than the whole picture.
Competent Practitioner
This stage includes planning backward from goals and greater responsibility.
Changes include:
- Setting priorities
- Planning and proceeding
- Breaking down problems
- Taking responsibility for decisions
Delegation can expand, although judgment may still rely heavily on deliberate analysis rather than an intuitive view.
Proficient Practitioner and Expert
A proficient practitioner recognizes important features of the whole situation and notices anomalies without examining every element separately.
At the expert stage, judgment and action become closely connected. The next move can feel natural, but explaining it becomes difficult. Strong performance does not automatically mean strong teaching.
See turning tacit knowledge into shared practices for using words, diagrams, and shared experience to make judgment accessible.
Guidance by Stage
Different stages need different support.
Give Beginners Procedures
Provide a foundation for action through:
- Checklists
- Procedures
- Concrete examples
- Frequent checks
“Think for yourself” alone does not provide that foundation.
Give Advanced Beginners More Cases
Broaden experience with both successes and failures.
Useful support includes:
- Similar cases
- Reasons behind judgments
- Limited discretion
- A habit of reflection
Gradually expand independent thinking.
Expand Responsibility at Later Stages
Competent, proficient, and expert practitioners need opportunities to judge.
Useful practices include:
- Sharing the goal
- Entrusting decisions
- Reviewing results
- Creating opportunities to teach
Micromanagement can be particularly counterproductive at the more experienced stages.
The Leader’s Own Stage
Use the model to examine your own judgment alongside the team’s.
Why Guidance Can Miss
A proficient leader may no longer see beginner difficulties. A competent practitioner may emphasize analysis and miss situational cues.
Your Next Learning Need
Review reliance on rules, cases, plans, the whole picture, or intuition. That reveals what to develop next.
Team Roles
Match routine tasks, planning, exceptions, and teaching support with current capability. A team spanning several stages can use those differences constructively.
SpreadSite is a no-code website builder that lets you create, publish, and update a website from Google Sheets using ready-made templates.
To share your team’s services and expertise through a website that is easy to maintain, give SpreadSite a try!
Build a website with SpreadSite →
About the Author
Thank you for reading!
I develop and operate SpreadSite, a service for creating websites from spreadsheets.
It helps people with limited time and money communicate what makes their work appealing. Consider it if you need a website! SpreadSite
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is the model limited to knowledge work?
A: No. It can inform learning in sales, service, driving, sport, music, and other skills where experience changes judgment.
Q: Why can progress stop at the competent stage?
A: Analysis and planning already produce results. Without discretion and experience of ambiguity or failure, broader situational judgment may remain undeveloped.
Q: Is extensive autonomy too early for a novice?
A: A novice first needs procedures and criteria. Unsupported discretion can exhaust both the learner and team.
Q: Is it a problem if an expert finds teaching difficult?
A: Intuitive judgment can be hard to verbalize. Questions and concrete cases help turn that knowledge into an explicit form.
Q: How can I identify my stage?
A: Examine whether rules, previous cases, plans, a whole-situation view, or intuition mainly guide your work.
