Who This Article Is For
- Owners and leaders who demand perfection from themselves
- People exhausted by imposing strict standards on others
- People strongly affected when events depart from expectations
Rigid “Should” Thinking: Replace Absolute Rules with More Flexible Judgments
Recognize demanding rules directed at yourself or others, question their basis, and practice more flexible wording while keeping goals and responsibility.
Published
Turning Ideals into Absolute Rules Can Put People Under Pressure
Rigid “should” thinking means imposing demanding rules on yourself or others. An owner must behave a certain way, failure is unacceptable, or employees must always act as expected. As these rules multiply, the gap with reality becomes painful.
Treating an ideal as absolute creates difficulty. Ideas from cognitive behavioral therapy offer a way to examine these assumptions. Retain goals while allowing a more flexible interpretation of what happens.
What Is “Should” Thinking?
It is a habit of deciding that something must happen or someone must behave in a particular way. The rule can concern yourself, other people, or the world. Cognitive behavioral approaches treat such rigid demands as a pattern that can worsen distress.
An owner should always be calm, a manager must never show difficulty, or employees must follow every instruction: these may sound reasonable until reality fails to match them.
The person often experiences the rule as a duty or truth, making it difficult to question. That conviction can become the starting point for distress.
Why It Feels Painful
People are imperfect, and plans sometimes change. A fixed internal rule leaves little room for this, so the discrepancy creates stress.
Rules directed inward can become self-rejection: the stricter the ban on failure, the harder a mistake feels. Rules directed outward can become anger or disappointment whenever others depart from expectations.
The strict interpretation attached to an event can intensify the response. Reviewing it provides a way to change repeated reactions.
Common Patterns
Responsible, conscientious, and successful people may become especially attached to demanding rules. A useful ability to regulate oneself can become excessive.
Examples include:
- Feeling deep shame over mistakes
- Strongly fearing inconvenience to others
- Carrying too much weight from a role
- Judging in black-and-white terms
Owners and managers can experience stronger demands because of their responsibilities.
Three Steps for Reviewing the Rule
Automatic thinking rarely changes through awareness alone. Treat the thought as something to examine.
Notice the “Should”
When angry, low, or strongly reactive, identify the words in your mind.
For example:
- I must never make this mistake
- They should keep every promise
- I should work harder
A strong emotion can indicate a demanding rule beneath it.
Question the Basis
Ask whether the demand is absolute, whether exceptions exist, and whether it is mainly your own standard.
Examine its reasonableness through facts rather than the intensity of the feeling. Many rules are personal standards that have become excessively strict.
Rephrase It
Reduce absolute language and use a statement that fits real circumstances.
| Rigid thought | More flexible wording |
|---|---|
| I must never fail | Mistakes happen; the response matters |
| Employees must follow my instructions | Check whether the intention was understood |
| I must always be perfect | Offer the best work possible now |
This is an adjustment toward reality while retaining responsibility.
Practice at Work
Repeated small revisions help make the approach usable.
Write the Thought Down
Recording the words creates distance. The statement becomes one interpretation you can inspect.
For a short writing practice, see Steps for Expressive Writing. It explains writing what is on your mind without polishing the form.
Review Demands Placed on Others
Rules for employees, family, or clients can create anger too. Consider the other person's circumstances before treating your expectation as universal.
That perspective can change the response.
Separate an Action from Personal Worth
A failed action does not define the whole person. Keeping that distinction prevents one event from becoming a total judgment about yourself.
SpreadSite is a no-code website builder that lets you create, publish, and update a website from Google Sheets using ready-made templates.
To explain your work and services clearly through a website you can keep improving, give SpreadSite a try!
Build a website with SpreadSite →
About the Author
Thank you for reading!
I develop and operate SpreadSite, a service for creating websites from spreadsheets.
It helps people with limited time and money communicate what makes their work appealing. Consider it if you need a website! SpreadSite
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: My demanding standards help me work hard. Should I give them up?
A: Keep useful goals. Review the absolute rule and how you respond when the ideal is not met.
Q: Will flexibility make me irresponsible?
A: Responsibility can coexist with less self-rejection. A more measured response can help you recover after mistakes.
Q: What if someone else imposes rigid rules on me?
A: Recognize their standard as their perspective. Some distance can help you assess what is actually required.
Q: How long does change take?
A: A thinking habit needs repeated practice. Notice, question, and rephrase over time.
